We use cookies to track visitor statistics and personalise adverts. This info is shared with Google. Only use the site if you agree to this. OK, I agree

Glenbuchat Heritage

124  Sir Archibald Michie
The Glenbuchat Image Library
124 Sir Archibald Michie

An obituary to Sir Archibald Michie grandson of William Michie of Belnaboth

Death of Sir Archibald Michie.
A Great Career Ended.

Sir Archibald Michie, K.C.M.G., Q.C, born 1813. He was a son of Archibald Michie of Aberrleen Place, Maida Vale, London, N. W., and grandson of William Michie, Belnaboth, Glenbucket, Aberdeenshire.

The following appeared in Melbourne Argus of 23rd June, 1899.

The news of the death, at the age of 86 years, of Sir Archibald Michie, Q.C., the last
representative of a group of great men who were distinguished in Victoria forty years ago
will be received with regret. Yet it will not surprise. Sir Archibald, it is well known, has been an invalid for many years, quite unable to leave his house, Tregarie, Alma-road, St. Kilda.
Though nursed with tender solicitude and comforted by the members of his family, the aged man gradually became weaker and weaker. About ten days ago he slipped and fell, and suffered an abrasion on the leg.
This developed into an abscess, and the simple necessary operation in such cases was an ordeal from which he never actually recovered. His end was hastened by the trouble, and he died late on Wednesday night, in the presence of Lady Michie and his son, Mr. William Michie. The funeral will take place on Sunday, and the St. Kilda Cemetery will be the scene
of the interment.

Sir Archibald belonged to a generation of public men in Victoria who were liberal by culture as well as in opinions ; and who combined high character and rectitude of conduct with exceptional ability, and a disposition to devote much valuable time to the discharge of political duties, in the fulfilment of which they were often called upon to make considerable
personal sacrifices. He was the son of a London merchant of the same name, living in what was then the suburban village of Maida Vale. in fact, it was only seven years old when the subject of this memoir was born there in 1813, having derived its name from the famous battle of Maida, fought in 1806. Educated at Westminster School, and entered at the Middle Temple, on attaining his one and twentieth year, the young law student was thrown into the society of men belonging to what was then called the school of philosophical radicals, which included John Stuart Mill, Bowring, Colonel Thompson, and the principal contributors to the
Westminster Review. He espoused their principles, and lived to hear them stigmatised as conservative and retrograde by a community which has deliberately abjured freedom of commerce. Called to the English bar in 1838, Mr. Michie resolved upon seeking a Jess crowded field of professional labour in a British colony, and sailed for Sydney in 1839,where he practised at the bar, and soon became known as an acute, ready-witted and successful pleader, with a quick eye for the weak points of an opponent's case ; great aptitude at repartee, and a clever knack of raising a laugh at the expense of a witness whom he wished to disconcert, or putting a jury into good humour by a caustic remark, an apposite anecdote or a diverting sally. But in those days the profession of a barrister was not so remunerative as it afterwards became, and Mr. Michie supplemented his legal earnings by contributing law reports and original articles to the press. in the year 1844 a weekly newspaper called the Atlas was started in Sydney. It was edited by Mr. (afterwards Sir James) Martin and one of its principal writers was Mr. Robert Lowe, afterwards Lord Sherbrooke, who had arrived in the colony two years previously. Mr. Michie and he struck up a friendship, and the former was pressed into the service of the Atlas, which also numbered Mr. William Forster among its contributors.

About 1848 Mr. Michie revisited England and made a lengthened stay there, but, in the meanwhile, the discoveries of gold in Australia had opened a new chapter in the history of these colonies, and he returned to them in 1852, selecting Victoria as a place of residence, and settling down in Melbourne, where he resumed the practice of his profession. He was
soon recognised as " a man of mark and likelihood," and having been admitted to the Victorian bar he was, in October, 1852, appointed by the Government a nominee member of the old Legislative Council, which used to hold its sittings in St. Patrick's Hall, Bourke-street west. He sat in that body for two sessions and then resigned, owing to the claims made
upon his time by his profession, and also by his having become part-owner of the Melbourne Heral. But the ability which he and the late Frederick Sinnett, one of his two partners, brought to bear upon the literary conduct of their property were inadequate to atone for its sadly defective business management, and at the end of two years, namely, in 1856, Mr. Michie retired from the concern, a very heavy loser by it.

After the unfortunate affair of the Euraka Stockade, when the Government had resolved upon the prosecution of the rioters, Mr. Michie, with other prominent barristers, volunteered to undertake the gratuitous defence of the prisoners, and, as is well known, the trial resulted in their acquittal. Soon afterwards the Constitution Act, framed by the old Legislative Council, and acquiesced in by the Imperial Parliament, was brought into force, and responsible government was established in Victoria. At the first general election Mr. Michie had the honour of being returned to the Legislative Assembly, in conjunction with Messrs. O'Shanassy, Stawell, David Moore, and J. T. Smith, for the city of Melbourne, and on the formation of the second Haines Administration, in April, 1857, Mr. Michie was offered and accepted the Attorney-Generalship, having for his colleagues Messrs. Ebden, Moore, Fellows, M'Culloch and Mitchell. The Ministry was displaced on the loth of March in the following year, and the late Attorney-General went into Opposition with his colleagues. in 1859 he was returned to the Legislative Assembly for the borough of St. Kilda, in which he resided, and continued to represent it until a fresh election occurred in 1861, when he did not seek re-election, but remained out of Parliament until 1863, when the defeat of the third O'Shanassy Administration was followed by the formation of an unusually strong Government, with Mr.(afterwards Sir James) M'CuUoch at its head. The two law offices in the Cabinet were filled by Mr. Higinbotham as Attorney-General and by Mr. Michie as
Minister of Justice. Only three years before his accession to office in this Ministry Mr. Michie had delivered an admirable lecture to a thronged and enthusiastic audience in the old Exhibition-building, entitled, "Victoria Suffering a Recovery," in which he had brought the artillery of his wit and logic to bear with destructive effect on that section of the community which was just then reviving the doctrines of " protection to native industry '

Holding these strong opinions on the fiscal question, and having held them all his life, the new Minister of Justice gave a painful shock to his friends by aiding his colleagues to reverse the public policy of the colony, which had previously been that of levying Customs duties for revenue purposes only, and to make protection its guiding principle in the matter of taxation.
After three years' experience of the anxieties and responsibilities of office during this troubled and turbulent period, Mr. Michie retired from office, and was succeeded by Mr.
Samuel Bindon as Minister of Justice. At the general election in 1866 he was returned to the Assembly by the electors of St Kilda, having previously represented Polwarth and Grenville. Two years later he successfully contested South Gippsland, and filled the office of Attorney-General in the third M'Culloch Administration from April, 187c, to June, 1S71. in the latter year he presented himself for re-election to the same constituency, but was defeated. in fact, it was not his good fortune to meet with an immediate renewal of trust from any electorate :
and the fact, paradoxical as it may sound, redounded to his credit. He declined to merge the representative in the delegate and commission agent.

Mr. Michie was afterwards elected to a seat in the Legislative Council, which he resigned in order to revisit Europe in 1872. On his return in the year following, Mr. Francis, who was then Premier of a Coalition Ministry, offered him the Agent-Generalship in London, vacant by the resignation of Sir George Verdon, who had filled the post from May, 1868, to February, 1872. Mr. Michie accepted the position, which he occupied until 1879, when he returned to Melbourne, having been created a K.C M.G. in the previous year. Sir Archibald Michie resumed practice as a barrister, and also, it is understood, the duties devolving upon him as the Melbourne correspondent of The Times, to which he was a contributor during many previous years. For the deceased gentleman was variously gifted, and his literary tastes and studies had always drawn him towards journalism, while he excelled as a causeur. A widely read man, he also possessed a retentive memory, in which was stored an inexhaustible fund of anecdote and apposite quotation wherewith to enrich his conversation with a keen sense of humour he combined the faculty of witty expression and a dramatic manner. Few raconteurs could tell a story so well or illustrate it more happily by voice and gesture, until advancing years had weakened the first and impaired the mobility of the second. The presence of Michie, Aspinall, and Ireland at a bar mess was sufficient not only to " set " but
to keep " the table in a roar," and their flashes of merriment, to quote the happy expression of Robert Herrick, " outdid the meat, outdid the frolic wine "

If conversation had not possessed the charm it did for Sir Archibald Michie, the probability is he might have made some permanent contribution to the literature of these colonies. He was well qualified to do so, but beyond the articles he wrote for the Sydney Atlas, for the Melbourne Herald and for Melbourne Punch, most of which are difficult of identification now, and dealt with topics of ephemeral interest, he has only left behind him the three lectures, together with the fragment of a fourth, and a treatise on "Victoria and Its Resources,, which he collected and published in a volume under the title of " Readings in Melbourne," while he was filling the office of Agent-General in London in 1879. And what is wittiest in his lectures suffers in the reading by the absence of the lecturer's voice and manner, which could lend such point to an epigram, such emphasis to a joke, such a mixture of vinegar and
honey to a sarcasm.

For upwards of 10 years past, as we have said, Sir Archibald was con- fined more or less to his house, advancing years and growing infirmities preventing him from maintaining the interest in public affairs for which his active mind and remarkable ability had in years gone by so well fitted him. He was content to remain within the circle of his family and immediate friends. They became his world, and the wider world outside almost forgot that one who had been such a leader among men as .Sir Archibald Michie undoubtedly was still lived. The deceased married in 1840 Miss Mary Richardson, daughter of Dr. John Richardson, Inspector-General of Hospitals, who survives him. He leaves three sons and two daughters, of the latter of whom Mrs. A'Beckett, wife of Air. Justice A'Beckett, is one. The eldest son is Mr. A. D. Michie, solicitor, the second Mr. William Michie, of Melbourne, and the third Mr. G. D. Michie, who is in the service of the P. and O. Company at Colombo.

The Anstralasian says : —

The death is announced to-day of an old colonist, who was for many years a very prominent figure on the Victorian political stage, a brilliant leader of the bar, and a cultured and attractive speaker on questions of social interest. During the past 20 years Sir Archibald Michie has not been much in the public eye, but in the decade following the early gold discoveries in this colony he was a man of mark- He won fame as a Parliamentary debater, showing considerable powers of sarcastic invective and satirical wit. A politician of generally liberal views, his defects were a want of fixity of principle and earnestness of conviction. Failing to associate himself with any distinctive policy, his impulses sometimes caused him to run counter to the more prominent formularies of the Liberal side. It thus happened that he never attained a commanding influence in political life, and that his greatest successes were reached rather in the arena of the lecture room than in the sphere of statesmanship.

Sir Archibald Michie was born in London in the year 1813, his family being of Scottish origin. He was called to the bar in 1838, and the following year he emigrated to Sydney. Engaged for a time as a law reporter for the press, he rapidly acquired a large practice. Having strong journalistic instincts, however, he associated himself with Robert Lowe (Lord
Sherbrooke) in the direction of a newspaper called the Atlas, which was devoted to Liberal politics. Mr. Michie also took an active part in the earlier struggles for popular rights in New South Wales. After paying a visit to England, he settled in Melbourne in 1852, Victoria, owing to the gold discoveries and the rapid influx of population, offering a much wider field for enterprise than the neighboring colony. Mr. Michie held a seat as a nominee member of the old Legislative Council, but he does not appear to have derived much satisfaction from the position, as he resigned it at the close of the second session. Throwing himself into the lucrative business of the Supreme Court, which was at that time yielding a rich harvest to able barristers, he gained distinction and reward. For many years he appeared on one side or the other in every great case that came before the courts. Some of his addresses to the jury were brilliant, dis- playing large and varied stores of information. in the year 1854 Mr. Michie became one of the principal proprietors of the He7-alpaid, and Mr. Michie had the satisfaction of knowing that he had maintained the integrity of his word. When the Ballarat rioters were placed on their trial, Mr. Michie gained popularity by placing his free services at their disposal, an act which required considerable courage.

The new constitution having been inaugurated, Mr. Michie was sought as a representative by the leading constituencies. He was returned to the Assembly for East Melbourne in September, 1856, and again in May, 1857, on his acceptance of the office of Attorney-General in the Haines Ministry. He subsequently sat in the Assembly two years for St. Kilda, and he gave to the debates at this time a vigor and a force which elevated the character
of the House. Always a zealous defender of the privileges of political and social liberty, he made a reputation which seemed to promise much future success. His forte was sarcastic invective, and the pleasure of the frav often led him to attack both friend and foe. On the lecture platform he was also highly successful. The old Exhibition Building in William
Street was often crowded in later years with an assemblage gathered together to hear him discourse on such topics as Shakspeare's plays and Victoria Suffering a Recovery, or Loyalty, RoyaUy and the Prince's Visit. in 1861 Mr. Michie retired from Parliament for a time, but during the period of general dissatisfaction which marked the closing months of the last O'Shanassy Administration a demand arose for a better order of things, and Mr. Michie was called upon to renounce his leisure and return to the field of political strife. He accordingly presented himself in 1863 for Polwarth and Grenville, and .was elected. On the formation of the M'Culloch Government immediately afterwards, he took office as Minister of Justice, and was therefore a member of the Government which introduced the protective policy which led to the memorable deadlocks and the recall of Sir Charles Darling, though Mr. Michie had resigned his position before the latter event took place. He retired from the M'Culloch Ministry in 1866, before the proposal of the Darling grant, but again took office as Attorney-General in the M'Culloch Government of 1870, which followed the M'Pherson Administration. in 1871 Mr. Michie was elected to the Legislative Council, but shortly afterwards losing his voice owing to an affection of the throat, he visited England with a view to recovering his health. When he returned in 1873, he was appointed Agent-General for the colony, with a salary of 2,000 per annum and allowances of 462. While holding this office he was made a K.C.M.G. He resigned the Agent-Generalship in 1879 and returned to Melbourne. He resumed practice at the bar, but a new generation had grown up, his old powers had somewhat waned and he never regained the leading position he once held
It as a lawyer. Nor did he again essay politics. The legislative measure with which Sir Archibald Michie's name is chiefly identified is the Single Bottle Bill, which survives in a form in the present grocer's licence to sell wine, beer and spirits. Sir Archibald died on 21st June 1899. He married in 1840, Mary, daughter of the late John Richardson, Esq., m.d., Inspector-General of Hospitals, and had —
Mary : died in France, unmarried. December 1846,
Archibald Donnelly, born in Sydney, Barrister and Solicitor, a Commissioner for all the Australian States, New Zealand, and Fiji, New Courts Chambers, 423, Chancery Lane, Melbourne. He married on 2nd March 1871, Kate Branch Orr.
Isabella : married Mr. Justice A'Beckett, of the State Supreme Court of Victoria.
Janet : unmarried.
William : General Agent, Cigar and Cigarette maker, 441, Little Collins Street, Melbourne.
Douglas Gordon : Agent, P. & O. S. N. Coy., Colombo. {See Colombo notes.)

Picture added on 14 November 2011 at 18:20
This picture is in the following groups
Please add your comments about this picture using the form below.


Your Name

Your email address - this will be shown on the page and will allow the system to notify you of further comments added to this picture.


55 Glenbuchat Newspaper Cuttings53 Glenbuchat Newspaper Cutings52 Glenbuchat Newspaper cuttings34  Alexander Walker Autobiography 1898  Comment33  Alexander Walker Autobiography 1898  Pt 632  Alexander Walker Autobiography 1898 Pt 531  Alexander Walker Autobiography 1898 Pt 4 30 Alexander Walker Autobiography 1898 Pt 329 Alexander Walker Autobiography 1898 Pt 228 Alexander Walker Autobiography 1898 Pt 1